Not every slip and fall case goes to court. In fact, most don’t. For some clients this can be a source of relief – the idea of sitting in a courtroom can be a scary prospect. For others, not going to court can be frustrating, after all if you were injured you may want to hold someone responsible. Fortunately, settlements mean that you can hold people accountable and get the compensation you deserve without going to court.

What Factors Determine Whether a Slip or Fall Case Goes to Court?

There are many different reasons why your slip and fall case may or may not go to court, including:

1)    The defendant’s insurance policy

In many cases, it can come down to the defendants policy. If your case is against a major national chain, they might simply choose to pay out rather than fight it in court. If your claim is against a small local business then it might make more sense for them to take your claim to court.

2) Public perception

Whoever said any publicity is good publicity has obviously never been sued. Many large businesses don’t want their name in the papers. They’d rather eat the cost of settling outside the courtroom than go through a protracted public lawsuit – even if their odds of winning are strong.

3) The liable party

It takes two to tango. Even if you and your lawyer want to cut a deal you still need the other side to agree. In some cases, they may be confident enough (or stubborn enough) to refuse to come to any agreement outside of the courtroom. Walmart was notorious for refusing to settle no matter what. They’d rather lose in the courtroom than make a deal. Today Walmart is a bit more reasonable but that tough reputation means that they have a strong negotiating position.

4) The judge

If a particular judge has an unfavourable record against slip and fall cases than your lawyer might advise against going to court. This is also why it’s a good idea to retain an experienced lawyer – they know not only the law, but also have experience dealing with particular judges, lawyers and organizations.

5) Your case

Every case is different. If your slip and fall was caught on tape, your injuries were clear and the defendant had a history of acting negligently, then you probably have a pretty good case. But if the evidence is weaker then it might be better to take a settlement.

6) You and your lawyer

An experienced lawyer who is not afraid to take your case to court can actually make settling a better option. The defendant won’t want to face the other party in the courtroom, and might instead agree to a more generous settlement. At the same time, the decision of whether or not to go to court is one that you should make with your lawyer, based on their advice. If you decide that you want to take the case all the way, then let your lawyer know.

Whether or not your case goes to court you need the trusted legal representation that you can find. Call Zayouna Law today to be put in touch with an experienced slip and fall lawyer.

Joseph Zayouna, LL.B, B.B.A - Zayouna Law Firm

Written by

Joseph Zayouna

Personal injury lawyer

Joseph Zayouna is the founder and managing partner of Zayouna Law Firm. Driven by a steadfast commitment to justice, Joseph discovered his passion for Personal Injury law early in his career. 

Recent Posts

A subcontractor worked on two nearby job sites for the same general contractor. The general contractor argued that the subcontractor’s lien rights on one of the sites had already expired. The Ontario Superior Court disagreed. In Bradley-Kelly Construction Ltd. v. GIP Construction Ontario East Ltd., 2026 ONSC 5180, released September 11, 2026, the Court considered […]

“You might have a case, but the optics stink.” That’s the conversation I sometimes have with a client when the paperwork might be defensible — but the story looks terrible. You froze your business partner out of the bank “temporarily.” You stopped answering the accountant. You moved inventory the night before mediation. You paid yourself […]

Sometimes the hardest advice to give a client is also the most important: “Sounds good, but you can’t do that.” After nearly 20 years as a litigator, I can say that conversation still doesn’t come easily. But one of the most important parts of litigation is making sure the remedy matches the legal interest that […]

CLIENT TESTIMONIALS

REAL STORIES. REAL SUPPORT.

SPEAK WITH A LAWYER TODAY

If you’re facing a legal challenge, you don’t have to navigate it alone. Start with a conversation. We’ll help you understand your options and the best path forward.