Accidents on the road are moments drivers never want to experience, but unfortunately, even the best drivers can find themselves in an accident. Maybe you had a slight fender bender. Or perhaps you accidentally stopped too late and rear-ended another driver. It can happen, and when it does, it can affect your auto insurance rates. Let’s take a look at how car accidents can affect your auto insurance and what you can do if you find yourself in a collision or other incidents on the roads.

Who is at fault?

This is the question that determines who holds the responsibility for the accident. Collisions with other drivers require insurers to use the Fault Determination Rules to determine who was at fault for the accident. These regulations outline different instances and rules that help identify who was responsible after an accident. This process can take time and can involve police investigation. If you are found to be at fault for the accident, you could face increases to your auto insurance premiums. 

How much will my insurance go up?

The amount your auto insurance premiums can increase after an accident can depend on certain factors. The Fault Determination Rules determines the amount of fault placed on drivers. It can typically be 0%, 25%, 50%, 75%, or 100% of your responsibility when an accident occurs. For 25% and above, there may be an increase in your premiums. Anything below that percentage and your rates are very likely not to increase. 

No-fault and accident forgiveness

In Ontario, no-fault insurance is a mandate that ensures insurance companies pay out claims on time. It doesn’t mean that no one is at fault for an accident, even though the name can lead people to believe that. Simply put, with no-fault insurance, you go through your insurer to get claims settled and don’t have to worry about directly dealing with the other driver. 

Accident forgiveness is an insurance add-on (called a rider) that helps protect drivers with good driving records from facing increases to their auto insurance premiums if they are at fault. It is not included in every policy and must be added on as a separate cost to your original auto insurance plan. It can’t protect you from rate increases for every incident on the roads, especially those outlined in the Ontario Highway Traffic Act.

What can I do?

The amount of time an accident can affect your auto insurance rates can differ depending on where you live and the severity of the accident. After some time has passed from when the accident has occurred and your insurance premiums have risen, you may be able to work with your insurer to help keep your rates more manageable. 

What if I need legal advice?

An accident can be a traumatic experience for people, leaving them feeling lost or unsure of what to do next. During these moments, it is a good idea to speak with a lawyer and understand your rights and help make sense of the situation. The personal injury lawyers at Zayouna Law are experienced in all areas of personal injury law, including motor vehicle accidents. If you have recently been in a car accident and are worried about how the incident will financially impact your family, contact us now for a free consultation.

Joseph Zayouna, LL.B, B.B.A - Zayouna Law Firm

Written by

Joseph Zayouna

Personal injury lawyer

Joseph Zayouna is the founder and managing partner of Zayouna Law Firm. Driven by a steadfast commitment to justice, Joseph discovered his passion for Personal Injury law early in his career. 

Recent Posts

A subcontractor worked on two nearby job sites for the same general contractor. The general contractor argued that the subcontractor’s lien rights on one of the sites had already expired. The Ontario Superior Court disagreed. In Bradley-Kelly Construction Ltd. v. GIP Construction Ontario East Ltd., 2026 ONSC 5180, released September 11, 2026, the Court considered […]

“You might have a case, but the optics stink.” That’s the conversation I sometimes have with a client when the paperwork might be defensible — but the story looks terrible. You froze your business partner out of the bank “temporarily.” You stopped answering the accountant. You moved inventory the night before mediation. You paid yourself […]

Sometimes the hardest advice to give a client is also the most important: “Sounds good, but you can’t do that.” After nearly 20 years as a litigator, I can say that conversation still doesn’t come easily. But one of the most important parts of litigation is making sure the remedy matches the legal interest that […]

CLIENT TESTIMONIALS

REAL STORIES. REAL SUPPORT.

SPEAK WITH A LAWYER TODAY

If you’re facing a legal challenge, you don’t have to navigate it alone. Start with a conversation. We’ll help you understand your options and the best path forward.